Monday, March 23, 2015

Attempt #47 - Old Chicago

Venue Outside
The Venue
77  2nd St.
Coralville, IA 52241
(319) 248-1220

Old Chicago has been around in various cities across the country for many years. Growing up in Rockford IL., I recall many times meeting up with old friends from High School there once it opened up around 2002. The Coralville, Iowa location isn't much different from the Rockford IL. location. The same decor, the same basic menu of foods loaded with calories and almost too many beers to count. I don't recall seeing a pool table at the Coralville location one (although we didn't go into the bar area, just walked by quickly). The location is actually quite a bit larger though, with additional rooms being added on to support a larger dinner/game crowd. The wait staff was very helpful and friendly - a good sign for being in a busy college town. The pizza didn't take too long to cook either. One cool thing about Old Chicago is that you can literally Google their menu straight from your web browser (no pesky .PDF file to scan through): Menu
Menu


The Pizza

Chicago Style:  Yes
Crust Thickness:  Thick and Thin (Average) 

Our group consisted of 5 participants, so we ordered three pizzas. They can come in three sizes (8" = Small, 12" Medium, 14" Large), with two styles of crust, Chicago Thick and Taven Thin (it is more like an average thickness).
Meat Me  - Loaded with Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, andouille sausage, pepperoni, green olive garnish, and fresh basil (14" Large, Chicago Thick, $24.95).
Pepperoni - Pepperoni (12" Medium, Chicago Thick, $16.05).
Pepperoni, Medium, 12", Chicago Thick Crust, $16.05
Royal Margherita - Pesto sauce, tomato bruschetta, roasted garlic, fresh mozzarella and basil olive oil. Finished with fresh basil (14" Large, Tavern Thin, $20.95).


Meat Me, Large 14", Chicago Thick Crust, $23.50
The Verdict

The pizza came out in circular-shaped pizzas with rectangle pieces for the Margretta and triangular pieces for the Meat and Pepperoni pizzas. The sauce was light on the pizza-it was good, but the pizza seemed to be a little dry and greasy.  The crust wasn't soggy, but instead was a firm bready texture.  Nor was it burn or over done.  The cheese was spread across the pizza well, without any saggy parts. The toppings were what you would expect for a $20 pizza from a chain-good but not plentiful. The Royal Margherita tasted much like bruschetta instead of pizza, so be warned, if you don't care for Basil, I would suggest skipping it altogether. For me the flavor of the sausage didn't seem quite right on the Meat Me (it tasted a bit sweat), so I opted to go with the Pepperoni. The flavor of the Pepperoni and cheese seemed to be much more complementary. Old Chicago serves up good average pizza. Overall the Pepperoni won the votes as the favorite in our participant pool. Currently, our average is a 7.75 so Old Chicago is clearly on the top half of our list for places to try.  A weeknight may be best as it can get quite busy on the weekend, especially  if a Iowa game is going on in town.

Here are our ratings, where 1 = worst and 10 = best.
Overall            7.90
Royal Margherita, Large 14", Taven Thin Crust, $20.95
Cheese            8.40
Sauce               7.40
Topping           8.60
Crust                8.40
Venue              8.50

No comments:

Post a Comment