Attempt #84 - Geyer's Oven

Entrance

The Venue
1259 Rohret Rd SW,

Oxford, Iowa 52322

(319) 828-4257

There are two Pizza farms in the eastern Iowa area that I am aware of. Stone wall (which we attempted back in Pizza Attempt #76 [September 2017]), and Geyer's Oven. From our knowledge, Geyers is the more popular, and closer to Iowa City, location. The Menu varies and during the summer months, one can find updates on their Facebook page.

All you can eat, however, you will need to wait in line. They usually run until 7:30 PM. $12 per adult, kids under 6 are free.

Long Lines

The Pizza

Chicago Style: No

Crust Thickness: Thin

Menu: https://www.facebook.com/Geyers-Oven-282157461899595/

Participants: 4 (plus 2 children)

Pizza Ordered: All

Sizes Offered/Ordered: Standard personal pan
Crusts Offered/Ordered: Standard Thin Crust

Pieces Cut: Triangular

Pepperoni/Cheese
BBQ Beef & Caramelized Onion

Meat Lovers – Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni

Menu

Ham, Black Beans, Spinach, Balsamic Glaze & 3 Cheese Blend

Sriracha Chicken with Pickled Red Onion

Southwestern – Black beans, green onions, cheddar, cilantro, taco sauce

Mean Green – With Spinach, green onion, garlic oil, 3 cheese blend

The Verdict

Sauce: Average.

Cheese: The cheese curd one (Ham) was awesome with the cheese.

Crust: A lot of burnt pieces, so I was disappointed. Most likely this was due to them being in a rush on openning night.

Toppings: A lot of interesting topping selections, which made their pizzas unique. Some were a little over the top (veggie with no dairy), but it was decent to try and appetizing.

Pizza Chief

Final Comments/Considerations: Personally,I preferred Stone Wall's pizza farm to Geyer's. Less crowd, more pizza, and more traditional toppings. Overall we felt it was a little overrated, but it was a nice property, with a cool garden fir the kids to play in.

Here are our ratings, where 1 = worst and 10 = best.Overall 7.75

Cheese 7.75

Sauce 6.75

Topping 7.00

Crust 7.25

Slices

Venue 9.50

Favorite: Undecided