Attempt #114 - Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub (10462 Olio Rd Fishers, IN 46040)

 

Venue Outside

Menu

The Venue 

10462 Olio Rd
Fishers, IN 46040
(317) 336-8703

 

Family owned small business with 15 years of experience being in the service industry.  They have a environmentally conscious approach to running their business, such as using bio-degradable products, and LED lighting, etc…  The Fishers location that we were at had both able and booth seating with a trendy restaurant all located in a (newer?) strip mall. 

Quattro Formaggio (Hand Tossed, 8 Inch, $13.70)

 

The Pizza

Chicago Style: No

Crust Thickness: Average

Menu:  https://pearlstreetnew.securetree.com/Geist/Menus/Pizza-Calzones/

Participants: 3 (0 children)

Pizza Ordered:  3

Sizes Offered/Ordered: 8”, 12”, 16”/ 3x 8”

Pieces Cut: Triangular

 

1.    Stuffed Portobello Mushroom - Sliced portobello caps, sausage, ham, bacon, red onions and mozzarella (Signature Pan, 8", $14.70).

Spicy Hawaiian (Signature Pan, 8 Inch, $14.70)

2.    Spicy Hawaiian - Pineapple, spicy capicola ham, spicy Thai-chili sauce and mozzarella. Topped with fresh cilantro (Signature Pan, 8", $14.70).

3.    Quattro Formaggio - Olive oil, garlic, asiago, mozzarella, parmesan and ricotta cheeses. Topped with fresh parsley (Hand Tossed, 8", $13.70).

 

The Verdict

Sauce: Sauce was a little too sweet for my likings, but it was well distributed. 

Stuffed Portobello Mushroom (Signature Pan, 8 Inch, $14.70)

Cheese:  The cheese was pretty light, and left more to be desired.  I LOVED the cheese around the crust on the pans, but it should have been more.  Lacked flavor.

Crust: Firm bready crust was a great asset to each pie that we ordered. 

Toppings: Tasty toppings, lots of flavor.

 

Final thoughts:  Next time, I wanted to try the pear pizza.  This place has two locations, so you know they are doing something right!  Lots of unique pizzas with a larger Italian menu.  Will definitely return!   

 

Here are our ratings, where 1 = worst and 10 = best.

Overall 8.67

Cheese 8.67

Topping 9.33

Sauce 9.00

Crust 7.71

Venue 7.29

Favorite: Spicy Hawaiian